Should HBCUs STILL exist?

During my research and discussions about my research, I am often asked the question of “should HBCUs still exist?” Yes. shockingly, as a graduate of an HBCU, initially I found it quite difficult to understand why anyone would question the existence of our institutions. I wondered if they were ignorant of the fact that although HBCUs account for only 2% of postsecondary education, they are ultimately responsible for producing over 20% of African American graduates. Although HBCUs access and financial resources may not be equal to PWIs across the board, research has shown that students learn more if not the same as their counterparts at Predominantly White Institutions (PWIs) in spite of these inequalities.

But still there’s this question of whether HBCUs should exist? Although I may have ill feelings towards this question it is one that should be asked. Through demonstrating the importance of our existence through our historical achievements and student academic gains we strongly support the existence of HBCUs. Below are examples of how people have questioned the existence of HBCUs:

  • Brown vs Board of Education allowed African American admissions into PWIs; as a result, enrollment at HBCUs decreased and HBCU enrollment has not increased since.
  • The better and brighter African American students and faculty attend PWIs (I beg to differ)
  • HBCU graduation rates at HBCUs are sub-par (Yes…but we must IMPROVE THEM!)
  • The federal government should not support HBCUs due to their diversity efforts at PWIs; thus seeming contradictory.

Yes, these are the arguments being made on the existence of HBCUs. I believe that some are valid and others invalid. However, my overall goal is to support the argument that HBCUs should exist because they serve a population of students that otherwise would not be afforded an opportunity to higher education. In doing so I ask you to ask more questions about HBCUs existence! Ask others outside of the “HBCU World” why should we continue to exist? What can occur within our institutions to improve our graduation rates and financial attainments? More importantly, what can we do to better ourselves as Alumni? Through these discussions we are better able to educate others about HBCUs and prove our existence.


One thought on “Should HBCUs STILL exist?

  1. After a nightmare experience at a HWCU and a nightmare experience at a PWHS, I will say personally for me that HBCUS are needed and that African men arent taking advantage of them. I for one never really did have the personality that fit mainstream America, but the type of personality that older African Americans admire, in the African American community I am seen as someone with intelligence and someone who can be a leader in mainstream America, I either have to confirm and assimilate or be marginalized. At 30 years of age, I have wasted much of my talents and youth in the illusion of inclusions, while HBCUs and African Americans arent immune to favoritism, nepotism and politics these are resources that we have neglected and I dont see most of us who enter majority white colleges coming out with degrees. I felt like my talents and my intelligence would have been better appreciated around real honest to goodness black intellectuals. African Americans men and females are wasting their prime years in dead end jobs, going to Universities where racist professors are doing more harm than good and missing out on potential jobs that HBCUs could offer, many of the young African American men sitting in prisons could have been Professors, Coaches etc etc We as African Americans are lost and are in trouble.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s